Dave D's Learning Log

Oops, it’s been nearly three weeks since my last post! A good chunk of that was spent on a holiday where I did not have access to a guitar, in spite of my best efforts. Oh well. It was a great trip nonetheless.

I’ve still been working on a few focus areas. One is solos with some bends in them to help build that dexterity up, and I continue to work on Listen to the Music. That has turned out to be a great song for a learner. It has some challenging strumming patterns as well as some cool Hendrix-style triad and double-stop work in the bridge. It’s not something I would have thought to learn on my own but I was glad I decided to take it up and go through all of the different sections. In a similar vein, I have been looking at “Free Ride” by the Edgar Winters band. The verse strumming is tying me in knots though, and it’s very fast.

On the solos side, I’ve been working on:

  • The Thrill is Gone (mostly put aside for now)
  • Strange Brew (mostly put aside for now, though it could probably use some polish)
  • Hotel California (first solo only—still not quite there but getting close)
  • Knockin’ on Heavens Door (first solo from the GnR version)
  • Nothing Else Matters (there’s one tricky lick that’s eluding me so far)

I’ve also considered looking at the solo for While My Guitar Gently Weeps but haven’t dug in yet, and I have been playing the outro solo to Hotel California mostly as a triad exercise.

High time I shared some videos… Nothing is perfect but it’s progress.



1 Like

Well yesterday was neat. I had some spare time and so picked up my guitar, as one does.

I’d been talking to my son. As I’ve mentioned, he’s 13 and recently has started picking up the guitar. He’s pretty fearless. He just hears something he likes and then tries to play it. He mentioned to me the other day that he thought he’d try playing the solo in Bohemian Rhapsody and had been surprised about how hard it was. I laughed and said “Yeah, Brian May is really, really good.”

But I had a bit of spare time and I’d never really looked at it so I pulled it up on Ultimate Guitar. I figured if nothing else I could play it really slowly and try a couple of the runs as just a fingering exercise. After going through it, I realized there was just one bar that was really, really hard for me, so I isolated it and tried to play just the first phrase, first really slowly, and then adding a bit of speed. Then I’d another note to it. Then another.

And you know what? I did it. Not at 100% speed, but certainly a lot faster than I thought I could.

It was just a really nice moment because I often have these moments where I doubt whether I am progressing and it just went to show me that yes, I actually am getting better. Nice way to end the week!

1 Like

Still plugging away at things. I have been splitting my time between practicing solos and practising songs with more difficult strumming patterns (that is, difficult for me—I find muted strums and syncopation tricky). I have not been spending much time at all doing exercises or running scales or anything like that, but I think that focusing on actual songs has been very helpful—I feel like I’ve made a good amount of progress lately relative to how long it usually takes me to notice improve.

Rhythm:

  • Don’t Dream It’s Over: Incredible song. I had learned the chords to this a long time ago but I never strummed it properly with the mutes and the correct rhythm. It’s coming along nicely.
  • Let It Ride: A BTO song… I’ve been kind of using the intro to this almost as an exercise, for something else in the vein of Listen to the Music.
  • Just What I Needed: I love the Cars. Again, I am not sure if I will learn the whole song, but the strumming pattern for the chorus is fun to play.
  • American Girl: This one’s FAST. I’m not near keeping up with it. I’m doing an okay job with most of the song but once it hits the triplets at the end I’m done. I’ve actually excerpted the triplets to use as a pull-off exercise, along with a section of Sultans of Swing and Stairway.

Solos:

  • Stairway to Heaven: Yes, picking this up again. I worked on it months (years?) ago but hit a wall with the speed. I wanted to pick it up again as a barometer and I think it does show that my skill has improved. I’m not at full speed yet but it’s getting better.
  • Nothing Else Matters: This is just getting some polishing work. There’s one lick in particular that is eluding me.
  • Sweet Child Of Mine: I am not sure if I’m close to being able to play all of this one but I’m giving it a shot. I can’t help but admire Slash’s phrasing.
  • Hey Joe: Another one I’d worked on before but never actually finished. I’m reasonably happy with where I am at with it now.
  • Don’t Dream It’s Over: Not the flashiest solo but one I like anyway. I decided to look at this because I am working on the rhythm guitar for this.

I have a lesson with my teacher on Wednesday. Last time we focused on rhythm patterns and he’s said he’d like to spend our hour together this week on solos. I’m eager to hear his feedback. I think I’ve come a long way from a few months ago but there are still some trouble spots.

The other thing I want to discuss with him is my practice routine, such as it is. I sometimes am not sure if I am focused enough, but I like having a few different songs to work on. It might be a matter of picking a couple of ones that I go into deeply like I did with Listen to the Music, with a bunch of other complementary pieces on the side to complement them. I sometimes feel like I am not really practising because I am not running scales etc but on the other hand I spent a long time probably not learning enough real music so maybe it balances out.

Meanwhile, my son continues to impress me with how quickly he picks things up. I may have said before but I told him if he started playing guitar he’d be better than me before long and I think that might be true sooner than I think! The whole family is chipping in to help him buy his first guitar for his birthday in a couple weeks and I can’t wait to see him rock out on it.

Exciting day today: we are going to pick up my son’s first electric guitar! It’s his birthday. He’s saved money to put toward it and various family members have given him enough money to cover the rest as a gift. I’m pretty excited (and not only because it means that I’ll get my guitar that he has been using back)!

I missed a few days of practising due to travel but picked things up again yesterday. I am still working through the Stairway solo and was feeling a bit frustrated. I slowed it right down and have been attacking it lick by lick, but still finding more challenging than I expected. My fingers keep fumbling and I am not entirely sure why. I might need to record myself playing and see if that will help me spot some technical thing that’s preventing me from getting faster.

Yesterday I also started working on the solo in Yellow Ledbetter. On this one I was pleasantly surprised—it wasn’t too bad at all. There’s one lick that I find a bit tricky but I think it’s manageable. The down side of working on this song is that it really needs a whammy bar for a couple of things, and I don’t have one of those presently (because my son’s been using that guitar). So we’ll see once I get that guitar back if I can manage it.

Also continuing to work on Don’t Dream It’s Over. I think I have the strumming pattern down pretty well but would benefit from building up some muscle endurance in my hand with all those barre chords. This is a good one to work on for that, though.

Final note… I was the lucky recipient of a generous gift card for my local guitar store and I am trying to think of what to spend it on. I am thinking of selling a few things to put together some money to get something nice. I’ve wanted an offset for a while but I have also been thinking about upgrading my “s-style” (sorry, Bud) partscater. I am not sure what I could get for it in a trade but it might be worth exploring. I am going to play it a bit after I get it back from my son to see how I feel but the local store has a really nice G&L S-500 as well as a Player II Strat that both felt pretty good. On the other hand, I have also been thinking about replacing my Katana with something like a Nano Cortex or a Tonex pedal, or maybe even just going crazy an getting a tube amp. No rush on it but I think when we’re at the store today I might take some time to play myself…

2 Likes

Celebrating the acquisition of my new guitar, a 1996/7(?) G&L USA S-500… Here’s a quick recording of something I’ve been working on for the last few days, “I Need Your Love So Bad” by Peter Green’s Fleetwood Mac.

It wasn’t my best take but they’re working on the road behind my house and so there’s a lot of random construction noise. The guitar sounds much better in person than it does on my little iPhone mic…

4 Likes

Great start to this awesome tune David!

You’ve got the basic rhythm down well, which seems to be problematic for alot of people initially.
You’ll get alot of enjoyment and satisfaction learning this song, and it’ll teach you much.
Sweet new guitar too!

Looking forward to future renditions.

Cheers, Shane

1 Like

You re rushing
To play this solo you need to slow down
especially the bends
hold the note when you bend
one of the bend in the solo is a crying bend , you have to bend slowly to get it right

play against the original track to get the tempo right and add dynamics :slight_smile:

1 Like

Respectfully, he’s been at it a few days. Getting the notes down and the tempo is a great starting foundation. Many don’t lock into the tempo of this song so quickly, and are all over the place.
The ‘crying bends’ and other details etc will come in time.
He’s doing well.

1 Like

doesnt change a thing

the next step is to nail the tempo , slow down the bends and to work on the different types of bends

I think part of the rushing is the general panic that takes over whenever I start filming myself! But I know what you mean—Peter Green’s version is quite a bit more expressive. It’s something I know I need to work on but I generally want to get the notes under my fingers and then I will start polishing. I think the backup track I was using runs a bit fast as well, at least compared to some of the performances I watched on YouTube.

1 Like

its mostly the bends
try to hold the notes longer when bending , not just up and down hop its done

once you ll get this , you ll play it very nicely

1 Like

The original is @ 74 bpm, so aim for around that.
Your tempo feel in the song, after only a few days, is pretty good. It’s just the shortened notes you are playing at present that makes it sound ‘faster’; completely normal after only a few days at it.

With practice, as you allow those notes to ‘hang’ a little, via bending/ vibrato etc, it’ll all sound alot more expressive.
This is a deceptively difficult tune to play well. Well worth the effort though.

Cheers, Shane

1 Like

Is it really that fast? I was trying to tap out the beat from this video on my metronome and I was getting 50. The backing track I was using was at 60.

Yep, It’s definitely @ 74 bpm.
The 12/8 time signature ( some would say 6/8) might be throwing you off, if you’re trying to feel it in 4/4.

Cheers, Shane

That would explain it—I was counting it in 4.

Hello Dave.

There’s nothing harsh or aggressive about Peter Green’s solo. I like to play it as a reminder to play with a light touch.
Keep going with it and listen to the original to find all those little nuances.

1 Like

Continuing to work away at refining Need Your Love So Bad. The little red recording light continues to freak me out and so I don’t know if this is the best representation of where it is at. When I play it without recording I have grown to appreciate the value of a very soft touch. When I get nervous, I sometimes lose that a bit.

Also just for fun here’s the solo from Yellow Ledbetter. I flubbed the one run toward the end but again, when I don’t have that intimidating red light flashing at me it feels pretty close to a good place. Haven’t incorporated the whammy bar stuff yet…

2 Likes

Great stuff, Dave!

Need Your Love So Bad is far better. You’re definitely playing it with a lighter touch.
Keep going with it. Some of the notes in the original are really short - Justin describes them as being like a full stop.
There should be a tone and a half bend in there which Peter Green plays then lets it down a semitone. You’re playing it as two separate tone bends. A tone and a half bend isn’t easy but will sound great if you can nail it.
Great improvement over just a few days!

The other one sounds pretty good but I don’t know it so I can’t comment any further.

1 Like

Good stuff David. Lots of great (and a few quite tricky) bends to practice in this one.

Re the rhythm. Be ever mindful that this is in 12/8, with a swing triplet feel…so 123, 456…etc …with the pulse on the first beat.

Cheers, Shane

1 Like

After a few cycles where I was really focused on learning solos, I am now trying to build up my strumming chops. I think I’d always taken my strumming for granted but looking at playing “American Girl” has helped me identify that I probably need to work a bit on strumming speed and endurance, while “Listen to the Music” showed me that getting my left-hand working as a pendulum in constant motion isn’t something I’d ever mastered before. When I self-taught, nobody ever told me that that was valuable, so I always just winged it but I think not getting that basic technique has led to me hitting a limit that I now need to overcome.

To that end, I am continuing to work on American Girl. I’m focused on the sixteenth-note octaves primarily (I think Mike’s part?). I’ve found that once I hit about 100BPM I can maintain the sixteenths but lose the accents that are so important in that song. So, I’m slowing it down and going to build speed back up again.

I also have been looking at some other songs that have a driving rhythm like that. A similar song is “Last Nite” by the Strokes which I picked up. I found it a lot easier than “American Girl” and I think I can probably consider it a campfire song. I also have some others on my list: Should I Stay or Should I Go," “The One I Love,” and “What I Like About You.” These are meant to just get the pulse going and build up some more endurance. Then I’ll start to add complexity with some other rhythm patterns or syncopation. This is really a back to basics things to try to look back at things I might need to un-learn from my self-taught days and establish new habits and muscle memory. I do think the left-hand pendulum is coming along.

I am still working on solos and lead stuff, of course. I have been working on “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” recently (the Clapton solo, not Prince’s!) and it’s a real workout in terms of bends. I have also been playing the first solo in “Wish You Were Here.” I like playing more aggressive solos alongside ones that are really about touch and light articulation. It’s a good study in contrasts.

I also continue to chip away at the “Stairway” solo and… it’s frustrating. I feel like I just can’t build up speed. I slow down, play it through, and then ease up the metronome (by 3 bpm a day) but I’m not able to get to full speed. The most I can do is about 83BPM, and even then, I can’t play it cleanly every time. So I slow it down again, and build again, and hit a wall again. I’ve been trying to improve this solo forever, it feels like, and it bugs me that I can’t get past it.

I am still loving my new G&L guitar. I found a guy who will re-wire the pickups back to the S-500 passive treble and bass controls which I am excited about—just waiting for him to get the components ordered and then I’ll hand it over for a couple of days. It’s going to be hard to say goodbye. It’s been pretty much the only guitar I’ve played since I have got it.

I also picked up Dan Erlewine’s book “How To Make Your Guitar Play Great.” I want to learn how to do my own setup and repairs and so I have it in my head now to try to find cheap used guitars, fix them up and set them up, and then donate them to music schools or programs.