I also don’t sing and have faced this problem for years. The first stages of learning guitar involve chords, strumming, notions of rhythm, etc. Aside from learning some standalone riffs, you’re not really playing melody lines and so without singing, the songs are not really recognizable. And by “first stages”, I mean the first 2-3 years. Maybe middle of Grade 3 in Justin’s course, something like that.
So, if you don’t sing, what to do?
-
My personal solution was to close myself in my bedroom and sing along, no matter how bad I was. I was like the tree falling in the forest when nobody was there. I played songs that I loved (mostly Dylan) and it felt good, even if I couldn’t carry a tune in a bucket, as the saying goes.
-
Another option is to play along with the original recording. Most teachers highly recommend this and I found it to be pretty satisfying.
-
Option 3 is to get friendly with someone who can sing. For a while I dated a gal who could sing like a songbird and I played a lot while she sang. It was great.
-
Play with other people. Somebody will probably sing and even if they don’t, getting a good jam together is fun. (Not so easy to arrange for many people, including myself.)
Eventually, you will get to the level where you can start incorporating some melody into your playing. In a previous thread, I posted some ideas of how to start on that. Mind you, Module 5 is not advanced enough for this advice, but eventually you will get there: