Was thinking of posting my very first ‘A-VoYP’ of exactly this song and found your interpretation while trying to find out where I should post it. Still trying to build up to doing it!
Anyhoo, well done. I see that this vid is a year old now. I hope that your guitar journey here is continuing well.
Hi and thanks for your feedback! I think this song is such a great intro to fingerstyle. It has an awesome bridge and a super cool structure… so much depth in the simplicity. I hope you do post your version.
I have been doing more housework than guitar practice lately but still play almost daily and have worked through Beginner 2. I am planning on posting my final exam songs soon.
Have fun and in case I don’t catch it please tag me on your Chocolate Jesus rendition.
The song that makes my wife’s ears bleed just because she’s heard me belting it out early every morning for about a year now. I’ve worked my way slowly up to playing the key changes too, but my range is nowhere close to Johnny’s and so I have to start an octave higher and then drop it down for the middle verse. My guitar sounds terrible capo-ed up to A on this song and I struggle making all the changes work if I start it in A then move A-D-G-D-A.
It’s a truly amazing and challenging song with all the key changes in there. I will never be able to do it justice but I’ll keep on trying, much to my wife’s discontent.
Thank you for your kind comments. I get pretty OCD about nailing the key changes but maybe I’ve done enough trickery that you can’t hear me flubbing my way through them.
In the middle of Grade 1 I started studying classic country and realized it’s a lot of standard 1-4-5 open chords.
“I Walk The Line” played properly and with the actual chords (not muted and scratchy like Cash recorded it) is a real masterpiece of this form. It may be the piece de resistance of all classic country songs. The chord changes are simple but the key changes and the way they showcase Johnny’s vocal range are brilliant. To be honest I never really cared much for Johnny Cash until I started playing “I Walk The Line”, and I realized he was a genius.
As I’ve studied more of these songs I’ve realized that many of them share a simple chord structure but there are some really amazing variations that to my ears make each song very special.
My progression plan is to work the Justinguitar material but also to go deep into classic country. In fact my big crazy goal is to start a classic country cover band.
I hope you will bear with me as I try some of these songs out on this forum. Lefty Frizzell, Ernest Tubb, The Louvin Brothers, Buck Owens… all my new musical heroes with songs I hope to repopularize in my own little way.
Funny story about my relationship with country music… when I was growing up I HATED country. My dad always had the modern country station on the radio. I thought it was complete garbage. But in my town there was also a band with guys who were from the central valley of California and I started really digging their sound. They had the Bakersfield Sound thing going along with some Graham Parsons. All original music, all very sweet sounding and personal. Beautiful harmony singing. I moved out of my hometown about 25 years ago. I’ve been listening to “alt country” for a long time but didn’t start listening to the classics until about 10 years ago. I like a lot of it but didn’t really start getting into it until I played it myself and I realized there is a lot to love in these songs.
Very well done indeed Dan! The rhythm, bass lines, singing, seamless key changes. You’ve obviously put a lot if work into this and it certainly shows.
While not exactly a country music lover, I’ll certainly welcome more of those great tunes from you mate.
Dan, I recommend taking a listen to some of his American Series albums. These are almost all covers, his interpretations, produced with Rick Rubin. His rendition of Hurt and One appeal to me personally more than the originals.
I wouldn’t mind waking up to this song until my last day, as long as you wouldn’t play too early! another fine one from your hat, and I didn’t mind your voice and key changing, I think it was a lot better than great!
The first time I listened to Cash actually was American Recordings! My high school English teacher who I really respected and am friends with to this day recommended it. I thought it was cool at the time but kinda over my head. I was and still am into “college rock”… think Nirvana, Pavement, Shellac, Slint, and a lot of really out there stuff. Looking at Cash’s discog I am surprised to see there are 6 volumes of the American Recordings. I will have to check them all out. Thanks for the recommendation.