I love Gilmour and even more now for his honesty and humor. And feel a heck of a lot better for not being able to remember tons of songs. It has been a big frustration for me to be so dependent on tabs and lyrics for songs I should know in my sleep by now!!
@JanKR1953
We must be about the same age but I have only being doing Justinās Grade 1 lessons for four months so not your experience.
I have to work very hard to remember the lyrics, donāt think it is an age thing with me, at least I hope not, I was absolutely hopeless at remembering poetry at school.
I try to remember a key word in each line and sometimes my brain fills in the gaps.
Possibly been mentioned, but a great method I find is physically writing out the song in your own songbook, including the song sections, chords, strumming patterns etc where applicable. I find this personalised approach makes it my own and helps to nail the various elements down quicker. The more senses you can include when learning something the better.
It becomes a living document that can be annotated over time as you develop.
Cheers, Shane
4 Likes
Haha, that reminds of of when I was back in school and all my mates used to write out ācribā notes to refer to in exams. I tried this method out a couple of times, but found that by the time I had decided what I needed to put down on the note and had written it out by hand, I knew the information and the cheat became superflous 
It went wrong because of the dry ice covering his folder so he couldnāt see them lol.
1 Like
Iām at the same level as you grade 2 module 12
What work for me was picking a favorite song ( one I really wanted to play completely through) breaking it in pieces , writing it down, practicing it with app and with the actual song played. Basically you got to buckle down and commit to just that one song for a few lessons and drill your brain on the chord changes even when not actually playing like riding in the car and challenging yourself to see how far you can go in your mind before you get lost recalling the chords.
2 Likes
Hi Michael,
I think you have a few years on me - not lot, but clearly some!
I have been using Justinās lessons since about July 2021, and got first guitar April 2021. progress with modules has fallen off a bit as I am trying to pick up some of the shortcomings I notice due to āgraduatingā myself before mastery. I generally think this is ok as long as I am willing to go back and pick up the rough spots.
I donāt have trouble with lyrics so much - I seem to have learned them in my youth, even the songs about a generation before my time. However, if I start to LISTEN to the song, I start to forget what to PLAY, and that suggests I really donāt know what I am playing yet. I have a lot of trouble with patterns of notes/chords that do not have well defined groupings. I seem to do ok remembering some songs, like Asturias (just the beginning section so far), where there are a lot of repeating themes, but something that takes 16 bars to get back around to repeating looks like it will just take the brute-force method of repetition.
I enjoyed your Learning Log. I had looked at it when it was new and fun to see your recent notes as you progress!
2 Likes
Thanks for the kind words and encouragement.
Trying to learn the words for me will hopefully a bit like years ago when I was driving and listening to a tape or CD with the tracks in order. I would have no idea what the next track would be until the instant the last one finished then my subconscious mind kicked in and I knew what was coming and sometimes the exact gap between tracks. It was all a bit surprising but the brain can multitask.
I have been working on remembering the lyrics and it is starting to come together.
Even the great performers sometimes have problems remembering songs. A truly classic example is Ella Fitzgerald performing Mack The Knife live in Berlin. Check out how she handled forgetting the lyrics:
(18) Mack The Knife- Mack The Knife - Ella In Berlin.wmv - YouTube
It happens at 1:40-2:08
Glen
I also struggle with memorising songs, and Iām now re-organizing a new songbook printing out only the lyrics, working first with a Word Processor to get a clear structure of the song. Then pencil and rubber for the chords, I try to play without the chords, write them with a pencil, erase and again pencil and rubber until I have memorised themā¦at this point I write them with a pen and that song can be collected in my new songbook.
2 Likes
Train my ear to know exactly when to change the chordā¦Iām working on this, as it seems to me the main thing if I want to play confidently a song and focus on other aspects like rhythm and feeling and not struggling to remember the chordsā¦our ears should be able to remember, they just need to be trained.
This is a fascinating topic and something I have been thinking about a lot recently. I have been considering purchasing the app, but like others I think it helps with playing songs, not necessarily with memorizing songs. I think maybe you need a mixture of both the app and a structured way of seeing the song. Will follow along with this topic looking for tips and tricks, as I am still on the fence about the app, and will try to find a way to create a songbook. I use Justinās beginner songbooks, but will probably benefit from writing out my own.
Tl;dr I have aphantasia (self diagnosed) which means that I can not visualize things in my mind. For example I rarely dream, struggle with relaxation things, like picture yourself on a beach. I know what a beach looks like but donāt have a mental image. So did wonder whether I was unique but apparently not. I see the app as like a GPS, vs a map. If I use a GPS, getting to a place is easier, but I have little recollection about the route in future. If I use a map, and navigate with landmarks, then I could go back again. This has also reminded me of my past I used to work doing manufacturing support at Kodak, and the inside of the buildings were old and like mazes. We used to be shown to locations in the light, but when they were manufacturing it was totally dark, donāt be fooled by the movies where they show things in dim red lights. Most places were pitch black with only a few pinpoints of glowing strips. Memorizing your way by landmarks totally failed when the lights were out, so you had to remember directions in a structured way. Back to guitar, I also use Rocksmith, which to me, behaves like the app, in that it teaches you to follow along and shows whether you are improving but does little to help you memorize a song. Sorry for the rambling post but as I said I find this fascinating and am really happy that it is not just me.
1 Like
Good comment from @GreenRider in another similar question:
Practice chord sequences like 1-min changes
1 Like