Buckets of Rain and Girl from the North Country - Bob Dylan

Here are a couple of songs I have learned last month after watching the film “A complete Unknown”. There has been some discussion about the pros and cons of the film elsewhere, no need to repeat that. But what watching the movie did for me was to create context for the earlier Bob Dylan songs. I never liked the old recordings much - there’s just something about the sound of his guitar and voice that has always put me off. Hearing these early songs but much better produced made me enjoy and like them - they clicked for the first time really. So here I am, several songs in.

Buckets of Rain is of course from a decade later than shown in the film but it is such a great song and had been sitting on my bucket list (hehe, little pun here :wink: ) for a while. This year is the Open D year and so it was the first one up.

As for Girl from the North Coutry I used to only like the Johnny Cash version (because of the above) but the song was featured in the film in a relatively short clip but it sounded really good, so I gave it a try and it has grown on me - I think only play the fingerpicked version from now on.

22 Likes

You’re playing my kind of music Molly. And beautifully too.
:slight_smile:

1 Like

Hey Richard, you got to the words before I did.

Really, really nice Molly. I’m looking forward to the time when I’m able to play and sing as well as you do! But, sooner than that, I’m looking forward to other postings of yours.

1 Like

Really enjoyed these Bob Dylan covers. Personally I really enjoyed the film, perhaps hearing all those great songs coming over the sound system at the cinema!
Fingerpicking and singing most impressive, thank you
Richard

1 Like

Those were really good Molly. I am most familiar with the Wood Brothers version of Buckets of Rain. Your finger style playing is wonderful and voice compliments the playing very well. I quite enjoyed both songs.

1 Like

Beautifully performed, Molly. Thank you for sharing!

1 Like

Awesome sound and perfect fingerstyle playing. Congrats! :slight_smile: :+1:

1 Like

Wow Molly! Beautiful singing and playing. In many AVOYPS you can see and hear some student tension coming through in the notes and the voice. Not yours - so smooth and relaxed. Keep the songs coming.

1 Like

[quote="mfeeney0110, post:8, topic:396615”]
you can see and hear some student tension coming through in the notes and the voice. Not yours -
[/quote]

you can be a student all your life but Molly is way above the beginner stage :sweat_smile:

it was awesome !

1 Like

I might just be thinking of a Vintage Club looking at open D.
Watch out for announcements.

5 Likes

Great fingerstyle and voice. Thanks for share. :slight_smile:

1 Like

Thank you @mundeli, RIchar @Richtrfc, Joe @frito, Jason @J.W.C, Tomasz @Coda, Michael @mfeeney0110, Deborah @GrumpyMac and Michal @Carreta for stepping by and leaving a comment! I am glad you enjoyed the songs! But belive me, there still is tension and adrenalin pumping when I hit the record button, and mistakes all over and messed up lyrics - but with these two songs in particular I found it easier to get into the flow of things and just “go with it”.

And thank you also Richard @Richard_close2u for your comments! I will definitly watch out for that Open D Vintage Club. When I started learning Buckets of Rain that was the first time I had tuned my guitar to Open D and woooowww it sounds so cool. I’m already on the next Open D song and have set my eyes on a few more …

2 Likes

Sounds all too familiar to me… :wink: I become particularly tense when I’m about to overdub a perfectly recorded first track… :face_with_hand_over_mouth: It’s strange, since I know I can delete a track with some mistakes and make another attempt. I don’t have to pay for the studio time, there’s no audience and still something like stage fright gets in the way. After all these years… :blush:

Both pieces were fabulous Molly. Really beautiful playing and top notch vocals :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:. That was very enjoyable.

1 Like

Oh thank you so much Eddie @Eddie_09 !

1 Like

Your playing is truly up to snuff and beyond. Hey, I come here to listen to guitar music, so these tracks are worth the price of admission. :slight_smile:

I do think that the keys may not be the best for your vocal range. Know that you are not bound by the key that the song is originally played or whatever tutorial you worked with. Consider moving that capo around to find a more comfortable key for your singing. The chords remain the same as you move your capo around the neck. Feel free to consider or disregard, as your playing is truly a cut above. :+1:

1 Like

Thank you so much Clint @CT for stopping by, watching the videos and leaving a comment!

And yes, choosing a key was a bit of a challenge here - I’ve gone even beyond capo in the past and transposed songs so they suit me better, so no stranger to that. But these Bob Dylan songs a miles away from my vocal comfort zone. Always too low, and then an octave higher too high. Buckets of Rain was recorded in Open E and uses 12 frets so that limits my options. I could have put a capo high up, but my guitar has no cutout and in the end I decided to go down one tone and have the guitar in Open D and sing high. For Girl from the North Country same challenge, I started out with Capo two frets higher up but still had to change the melody a bit :slight_smile: and after that I went back to the recording key as I find that more comfortable for singing - even though it sounds better with capo two frets higher. Maybe do one thing for practise and another for performance :thinking:

2 Likes

Great answer @MollyT , makes me like these tracks even more! Play on playa!

1 Like

Molly

Many of Bob Dylan’s songs are miles away from his vocal comfort range! So you’re doing well making such tuneful renditions.

Brian

1 Like

Molly, your playing is fantastic! Flying and floating all over those strings. Vocals too. Great songs. I’ve never gotten into Bob Dylan, which is my loss. I do plan on watching the movie and sad I missed it in theater. You have given me even more desire to check out his music. Also looking forward to your next performance.