Can you use a metronome too much 
13 Likes
Better than ātik tokā 
8 Likes
Probably less repetitive too
1 Like
Not in my house you canāt!!! I have a stand alone digital metronome but that sucker is getting a workout lately. .
1 Like
I donāt think so.
Kinda like asking if itās better to play with a drummer or play w/o one. The drummer keeps everyone in time, together.
I guess. Unless your Ginger Baker, or Keith Moon. They were way out there good, but still kept the time, just with much frills outside of 1,2,3,4. 1,2,3,4.
Kinda cool that you got a record of how much you use your metronome too. This is good imho.
My windup taktell piccolo donāt keep record of how much I use it. Which I would guess would be, not enough.
1 Like
Maybe you should try turning it off when you are asleep?
3 Likes
The question is in the same category as:
Can I be too good looking or
Can I have too much money.
For me all three have the same answer.
Cheers,
Glen
1 Like
Good for you!
1 Like
Never too much! Isnāt it our best friend? 
1 Like
Iād say it depends on your situation. Playing to a click is great until you find yourself in a band, or open mic situations where you need to keep time with the song and not rely on a click!
2 Likes
Agreed. If I did a similar screenshot it would show I play 0% of the time to a metronome. I play along to songs and thatās how I practice keeping in time. If your band mates speed up or slow down then you need to match them not tell them how you were the only one who kept perfect time!
Sorry, the question was rhetorical! Although Iāve been using a metronome a lot recently as Iāve been working on timing very heavily.
Iām in the Blues Immersion world and Iāve been looking at a couple of things over there that really need a metronome ā¦
- Playing a 4 note repeated lick as 16th notes over a couple of bars then playing the same 4 notes as triplets for two bars.
- Setting a metronome very slow (30 bpm) and playing a slow unaccompanied blues solo using the clicks on beats 2 and 4 while trying to highlight the chord changes.
Personally I quite like the challenge of playing to a click, but I certainly donāt do it all the time.
I think a lot of bands will play to click tracks in IEMs these days.
5 Likes
Yes and donāt you wonder why? Similarly some famous singers use vocal pitch correction or even vocal over dub (mimeing) during live performances!
1 Like
Itās not the same at all.
Major bands have been playing live to click tracks for decades for good reasons. Often thereās backing tracks, sound effects, video or lighting that they need to synchronise with as part of the show.
Or, in some cases, thereās rhythmic effects, such as vibrato or keyboard arpeggiator sequences that need to be in time, and cannot easily be adjusted to match on the fly.
The ability to playing in time with a band also has very little to do with whether they are synchronized to a click or not.
When bands play to a click, it tends (in my experience of being the sound engineer for some local bands) to be only the drummer that has the click. The rest of the band are keeping time with the drummer and would be able to regardless of whether the drummerās tempo was drifting or locked to a click.
Cheers,
Keith
6 Likes
Great practice items Paul. I do different permutations of these types of drills often. Some with a metronome; some with BT. Many benefits I reckon.
Cheers, Shane
2 Likes
I think you can. Itās a necessary learning tool, particularly to get the rhythm and timing of a piece and increase speed. After you have that at the target tempo, you should turn it off. The metronome has served its purpose. Use your internal clock, move to a backing track, or better yet play with others.
Sorry but what is not the same?
The drummer using a click isnāt the same as using pitch correction or miming.
If you went to a āliveā performance and found out that the main singer had been miming through most of the performance, most people would, justifiably, feel they had been cheated.
Similarly, if you found out that a singer had been using pitch correction, then you may well be disappointed (depending on who the singer was).
But I doubt anyone has ever been remotely bothered that the drummer in the band they went to see used a metronome or click.
Because itās very common practice and playing along to a click doesnāt mean the drummer (or the rest of the band) canāt play without it. In fact, being able to drum to a click is a skill, and something a lot of drummers struggle to do.
Cheers,
Keith
3 Likes