Dee by O. Osbourne - Learning Diary

Dee is advanced for me, but…BUT…it’s so beautiful and I will court her until she’ll say “YES!” :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

Keeping a diary is proving to be hugely helpful, this is it until today, right below the video of these initial 7 bars! I put titles and pictures to make it more interesting to look at, I don’t expect anyone to read it…it’s too long!

PHASE 0

  • Justin’s Lesson

  • falling in love with the piece

  • creating a clip of Justin’s performance

  • compulsive listening

  • hearing it in my musical imagination

  • observing Justin’s fingers surfing the whole fretboard and taking into consideration the fact that I might not be able to nail it properly in the end

  • wondering “should I have a try even if it looks so advanced for my current level of skill?”

  • pondering, yes, there are a lot of pros in approaching it

  • needing to identify and write down shorter terms goals in order to avoid frustration

  • re-stringing my Classical Guitar since many months it was abandoned (I was definetely in a proper rut with it and I stopped practicing it).

DAY 1 - Should I stay or should I go? 13/12/2025

  • Eh?! The C shape G barre chord…no way! The hand is hurting and the notes are soo far from ringing out clearly; what if I don’t keep the chord shape down and fret the notes one by one? No, very bad idea, the G bass note needs to ring out ideally for the whole bar lenght … few attempts… this is impossible.
  • Why do I have to play the G on the 10th fret on the A string when there’s an almost identical G on the 5th fret on the D string? Oh wait… this is a D shape G barre chord I’m playing and sounds just the same! …few attempts…it’s challenging but still doable, I can make the notes ring out clear! I need to have a look at the whole musicsheet and make sure there’s not a specific reason for Justin choosing the C shape, before starting practicing it.
  • I’m much relieved the second chord is very easy! I also had a look at the following chord on bar 3: I never played harmonics, probably I should check the harmonics lesson before I get to bar 3; it doesn’t seem too difficult.
  • I can’t practice this piece sitting on the bed, I need a good posture, I’ll take my footstool out and practice in the kitchen, where I have a new (actually old) comfortable chair.

DAY 2 - Oh wow!

  • I had a closer look at the musicsheet and at Justin’s fingers in the video and I see no reason why I shouldn’t go for a D Shape G chord if it comes easier for my fingers.
  • The D shape G chord: I needed to go slow as keeping the fingers in that position hurts a bit and also I tend to have the fingers all tense after just a few repetitions; that made me take several breaks…but oh oh oh I can make all the notes ring out clearly and that little hammer-on is not impossible! I practiced the change to the following chord too.
  • I used the breaks to practice the change from the second chord to the harmonics on the 7th fret, and to explore the sound of the harmonics by adding…ah no no: by removing the pressure of the fretting finger!
  • I had a look at the chord on the following bar (4) to find out it doesn’t come difficult YAY!!! I decided I’ll do the harmonics with index instead of ring finger (as Justin does) because it makes the change to the next chord a lot easier for me as index is already in position on the 7th fret, it just needs to lift up a bit and go a tiny bit backwards!
  • I’m very happy to observe the fingerpicking hand goes on its own, I have to conciously bring my attention to it just to check it’s doing right.
  • The footstool: it is a very good idea, I adjusted it while practicing the Dshape G chord and worked looking at the camera on my phone to check the wrist to be as much straight as I can get it. This is the best I can do, also with curling the fingers on the frets.

  • Next step is to check oncemore Justin’s lesson and the instruction given for these 4 bars; I think it’s fine to make my variations to the fingerings if I have a good reason for it.
  • It would be really nice if I could check the lesson on harmonics too…but just by exploring it…uh it really sounded so sweet!!

DAY 3 - A nice sense of achievement

  • 10 minutes practice early in the morning just on the D shape G chord, not even using the picking hand, just holding the chord in position and from that making the movements to fret the notes I need, do that hammer-on with pinky and move to the next chord; holding it down for a prolonged time is not easy (the piece doesn’t require it btw) , so I did a few repetitions for each of the movements and then I found it easier for my fingers to practice the all sequence up to the harmonics on bar three. I thought I was reinforcing my fingers like that.
  • 30 minutes session late in the afternoon and it was so fulfilling! It seemed like my fingers had already made treasure of those 10 mins in the morning and were now moving more confidently. I practiced with both hands, my notes rang out clearly and I attempted to introduce some timing, not actually counting but listening to the recording and trying to rely on that. I also practiced the arpeggio on bar 4 which is super easy! I hadn’t set a specific amount of time for practicing and I could actually keep on going, but I was already very happy with myself, I played and sung my Hallelujah and put my guitar back to its place.
  • I checked the initial part of the lesson just before writing this, so far so good.
  • My fingers aren’t hurting but it feels like they have worked, especially on ring and pinky.

DAY 4 - Perfect starts slowly

  • I practiced up to bar 4: timing is still very rough, but it’ll soon fall into place once the motorskills are consolidated, because I can rely on how I can hear the piece in my musical imagination and just bring it out from there with no need to tap my foot; I think one of the reasons for my inclination to Classical Guitar is that I don’t have to tap my foot; no kidding, tapping my foot and coordinate it with my hands is often so much demanding, it has always been…bringing out a melody is way less demanding when you know it very well, no effort to keep time, because it’s already incorporated in the melody :slight_smile:
  • I added the change to bar 5 and this G chord here is super challenging! All I need to do is going super slow, move on finger per time to position them on the fret as best as I can to make the notes clear. Some observations: if ring finger is not well curved on the previous chord it will mute the G string; this last one can also be muted if pinky in its effort to reach the 10th fret pulls the all hand and index goes over the fret. This is a very complicated chord, nevertheless by going superslow and giving attention to the single fingers the notes ring out clearly…making the music flow will be challenging, hopefully not impossible.

DAY 5 - Back to some practice after a few days break

  • a short session today where I revisited all the shapes up to bar 5; my callouses were very dry and made it difficult to play all these pesky chords so I took good care of them afterwards.
  • slow slow slow movements of the fingers to build this G chord on bar 5.

DAY 6 - Starting to take form

  • Even if the hammer-on needs to be’ stronger I “already” can play up to the harmonics on bar 3 with a nice timing…yay!
  • This is all more than advanced for my fingers so there must be no hurry whatsoever in achieving results.
  • The G chord on bar 5 is less impossible than yesterday and I made some repetitions trying to observe the single fingers.

  • I had a look at bar 6 and 7…that little slide of pinky seems impossible too, but I don’t want to think about it, I’ll adopt the Scarlet O’ Hara strategy: “I’ll think about it tomorrow”.
  • Moving the shape up all at once is not really possible for my fingers, but it seems possible to re-make the shape quickly enough moving the single fingers.

DAY 7 - Fingers strenght or strategy?

  • I did some repetitions on the first 3 bars only trying also to isolate the first bar with the hammer-on and repeat that one over and over; I need to develop a stronger and louder hammer-on.
  • I found myself struggling oncemore with the transition Bm-G (4th to 5th bar), when I suddenly recalled I already faced a similar challenge with my fingers not being long/independent/strong enough to land in time on the frets: in that case after I guess about a year of consistent fingergym, I found out the whole hand and wrist can support the chord change (I’m a bit slow on the uptake, you know); I tried and the change is now quicker but more and more repetitions are needed to make it more accurate and smooth.
  • Moving up the shape in bar 6…this doesn’t seem too difficult by lifting up all fingers except for the root and re-build the shape.
  • The pinky slide on bar 6: I guess I won’t burn in hell if right before it I raise all the other fingers to make it confidently; I know the bass note should be held and ring out - but it’s impossible right now, I expect to be able to do that once my fingers will be stronger, or maybe I’ll find some sort of strategy for it as well. Anyway, hell doesn’t exist.
  • I took this little tool and gave the neck a few turns, as the Luthier on the Acoustic Guitar showed my husband who then showed to me. I can appreciate from watching the first fret how the strings got closer, but the action on the higher fret seems quite high still…I’m no expert but the difference between the first and the 12th fret is quite big!

DAY 8 - The “impossible-doable-possible-refined” progressive line

  • The pinky slide on bar 6: ok it happened, way sooner than expected, I did it holding the whole shape down! I can’t get much sound yet, but the movement of the fingers was possible today - just in case hell existed hahaha.
  • With this piece things are impossible one day and after just some practice the day after they become doable…and with more practice they get more and more refined; it’s the case too with the change from Bm to G (bar 5): today it was possible to just put down the two additional fingers, without moving the hand with great economy of movement! The G string still gets muted very easily: the main cause is now ring finger not being curled properly: more slow practice more refining!

DAY 9 - Visulisazion and left hand practice without right hand

  • I should mention that I started visualising right from day 1: I start with what I’m able to do and my mental pictures look/sound very much as drafts; along the way I aim to clearer pictures. I usually visualise before sleeping; last night I visualised the movement of the fingers, hearing the notes (not so clearly to be honest), keep time with foot and doing the counting. It’s the first time I do the counting, in my head only, it would be too difficult on the instrument at the moment. But it’s useful to be aware of it.
  • I practiced only the left hand and I was happy with myself. I tried to guess only by the feeling of ring finger if it was muting the G string or not. I added the change to bar 8 and from that to bar 9…yuppydooo bar 9 is super easy!!! Oh…among all these complicated shapes!

DAY 10 - The switch Bm - G is conquered!
…and here is the smile of satisfaction on my face after clean notes had been produced through most of my repetitions!

  • I had to restrain myself from moving on with the bars: the short term goal now is to refine this first phrase up to bar 7, record it and share it with this first part of my diary. It won’t be perfect, “as best as I can” will do :slight_smile:

DAY 11 - Moving the shape without raising the fingers

  • ihihih…the title says it all! It still requires a lot of repetitions to develop confidence but…well it makes sense to me, it wouldn’t be possible to move a shape which was not confidently nailed yet: as this pesky G chord is getting more and more stable it is now possible to move it up…and the slide with pinky also becomes easier.
  • I played the all sequence bar 1 to 7 a few times
  • I did more repetitions on the Bm-G switch
  • I did some repetition on first bar hammer on
  • I did some more exploring in the sound of the harmonics
  • I did some repetitions on moving up the G shape and the slide, it’s not smooth yet
  • I attempted to introduce some foot tapping and counting, somehow a timing seems to support the motor skill itself.
  • I’m pretty happy with myself :slight_smile:

DAY 12 - Recording and sharing Bars 1-7

  • Warm up - recording - sharing - more practice aftwards!
11 Likes

That was a really good cover for your first 12 Days!

1 Like

What a wonderful write up. It’s certainly a challenging piece you’re picked there, but it looks like it’s full of learning opportunities.

I love the way that the concentration on your face spreads to joy when the phrase is finished :slight_smile:

For some reason this reminds me of my favourite classical guitar piece, “Farewell” by Sergio Assad - I learned a chunk of this years ago, but haven’t played it in ages, perhaps I’ll dust it down again!

2 Likes

I did not realize Italians knew who Scarlet O’Hara was? Wow thats pretty cool Sil. :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

So true. :blush:

I have always loved this instrumental. Blizzard of Oz :sign_of_the_horns:t2:

Keep up the amazing work :clap:t2:

I really love how you go about learning a thing. And I can’t wait to hear the full piece.

1 Like

What a fantastic write-up, Silvia! That’s dedication to learning this piece. :slight_smile:

Your careful and mindful observation of all these little things is astonishing. Given that, it’s no big surprise for me that your progress on the first bars and the difficult shapes was that fast. You are so aware of everything going on. That’s a skill not everyone is lucky to have such as you have it. Great! :slight_smile:

The recording sounded sweet already! I neither know the piece, nor the lesson, yet, but you definitely made me curious! :smiley:

Looking forward to the next chapter!

2 Likes

Thanks for checking it Hans! It’ll be refined with more practice, at least all notes are clean now, that’s a good starting point!

Yes it absolutely is, what I find most valuable for me is that while I’m learning it I’m also developing good control over my fingers while surfing the all fretboard; this is something new to me. Justin describes really well the learning opportunities in the text below the video lesson on the website.

I checked it out as I didn’t know it, what a wonderful piece, so peaceful and melanchonic, it’s becoming now part of my Classical Guitar listenings, thank you!

Jason, Scarlet O’Hara, better known over here as Rossella O’Hara, is my all time heroine! I can’t count anymore how many times I read Gone with the wind, both in italian and in english…:thinking:…yes I’ll probably read it once more in 2026 :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

Oh you’ll have to wait…it might take months :sweat_smile:
Thanks Jason for your feedback, it’s always much appreciated!

I think this is a skill we all develop along the way, there are actually many things I was unaware of and that gradually with overall progress are now coming to my attention…I like to think of it as a journey to self-awareness and self discovery too. In this case going ridiculously slow is key, because when you go slow you give yourself the chance to observe more closely and spot details.

Oh…go and check it, it’s daunt - edit: hauntingly was what I meant, not daunt - my english fails me sometimes - hauntingly beautiful! I didn’t know it either, I gave myself a good huge amount of listening and I started learning it on the guitar once I could more or less hear it and sing it in my head.

Thanks for being always so encouraging Lisa :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

3 Likes

Thank you for sharing this Silvia! I’ve learnt a lot from your structured approach, detailed observations, and how you nudge/push/motivate yourself to tackle new challenges…

Nicely played too! Can’t wait for the full song next year!

1 Like

That’s so kind of you Ashu! I wrote it for myself, why not sharing it as well? To be honest I try to put at work all Justin’s best teachings, well…not all…only those that I’m able to understand, or better I’m ready to understand, in the different phases of my journey.

BEST WISHES FOR THE NEW YEAR EVERYONE! I especially liked @Lisa_S selection of priorities:

  • Health
  • Love
  • Music
    :musical_notes::grinning_face_with_big_eyes::heart::hugs::musical_notes:

A lot of these to all of you!

4 Likes

What a marvellous read, Silvia :slightly_smiling_face:

I felt as if I was learning just reading your diary ( what… there are D-shaped barre-chords?!?). I watched your video as well and the beginning sounded good already. I’m also glad to that your are feeling better

Please continue updating this post :star_struck:

1 Like

wow! Sylvia, bars 1-7 already sound so sweet! You’re really going to nail this!
I just love your write up too. It is so mindful and detailed. I learn a lot from your process. And especially the slowing it right down. I’m going to do this much more in 2026!
I’m looking forward to following your progress on this
Happy New Year to you too filled with health, love and music :musical_notes: :yellow_heart: :sunflower:

1 Like

@JokuMuu @Avalon426 you Ladies are always so supportive! My heartfelt thank you :smiling_face_with_three_hearts: I didn’t expect people would read my getting deeper to the details of my learning!

I will! In chuncks like this one - next one will be with a video up to bar 13 (the second prase is added) and the DAYS practice observations.

So powerful to achieve our goals!

2 Likes

Sharing Day! I love learning Dee! In the video I’m moving foward to beat 1 of bar 14; I’m playing while tapping my foot, so please still take it as a practice video. The reason for that is written below, in the learning diary. Many thanks to all those that started following my adventure, dropped a like or some words…I much felt your support :heart:

DAY 13 - Easy shapes on bars 8-13…YAY!

  • Today I worked with a timer and spent 5 minutes on two bars per time (1-7) using the metronome at 60 bpm; it hasn’t been super easy but I felt with more repetitions the notes fell into place; I had to take a few short breaks within the 5 minutes because it was demanding; working on all 7 bars with the metronome would be impossible now, I’ll build to that.
  • After doing my homework with the metronome I finally allowed myself to go on with the following bars (I already had a quick look yesterday to be honest). Eheh only easy shapes! I checked the lesson to see Justin’s fingerings and I applied them; I went slowly to memorise the sequence; something tells me it won’t take me too much to nail this second phrase, also the hammer-on on bar 13 comes decently easy. The real challenge will be to refine all, using a metronome seems a very good idea once both the motor and the memory skills are consolidated; it’ll help hugely!

DAY 14 - Practicing without the guitar

  • I slowed down to 70% the original recording on YT - I can’t emphasise enough how having a clip on my WhatsApp is handy . I worked on reading and following the music on the musicsheet while listening - Loads of repetitions, one phrase at the time, often isolating just two bars.

  • I stopped the Music to sing/ hear the 2 bars or whole phrase in my head while reading - loads of repetitions and tapping the beat with my hand along, starting with the counting and then without…ah I was right when I once wrote my short-term aural memory is so weak! I read mainly the Rhythm but also following the notes going up and down the staves helped a lot to hear in my head a bit more accurately where my melody was going - I re-listened to the bars/phrase any time I needed and then practice this hearing/singing in my head and tapping the beat, several times to consolidate the Rhythms. I’m happy I got that triplet really clear because…look what’s waiting for me in bar 15…sixteenth notes!

  • This is super powerful practice, I used to do it a lot with any new Classical Guitar piece…if the piece is Rhythmically clear in my mind the fingers will follow naturally on the guitar.

  • I worked up to bar 13 …or maybe beat 1 of bar 14, which is where the phrase seems to have a pause to restart immediately after…I’m not sure…

DAY 15 - More practicing :slight_smile:

  • After playing my beginner Carcassi Waltz to warm up my fingers, I set the timer at 5 minutes in which I just revisited all the shapes needed: the short term goal now is to learn this second phrase and add it to the first one.
  • 5 minutes I worked on phrase 1 with the metronome, but while I could keep time well a lot of notes from those pesky chords were not clean, so I thought the next 5 minutes to practice without the metronome just keeping time by tapping my foot; it went reasonably better, with less unclean notes. I don’t think there’s much to do other than keep on trying and get used to follow either the click or my foot tapping, clean notes will come back with more practice…it might be a good idea to just work on just a couple of bars per time, probably it was still too early to attempt the whole phrase.
  • I practiced the chord changes of phrase 2 and I’m happy to say I’m well on my way to have them memorised. I need to follow the same path of phrase 1: the motorskill and the memory skills first, then aim for accurate timing.
  • I need to check in the lesson how Justin frets the last note on bar 13, it comes natural to use index, but I had a look at the next bar and it seems like I will need index straight away to fret the A note on second fret…so maybe it might be worth to stretch a little bit more to reach that note with middle finger (?)

DAY 16 - Chord changes and tapping my foot

  • I sang the piece in my head last night, keeping time with my foot in the bed, silently counting and roughly visualising the movements of my fretting hand; Visualising is usually demanding, not this time though; on the contrary I was very relaxed, just going slow…I happened to think it was making me feel well.
  • I checked the lesson: yes, Justin also frets that last note with middle finger, like this the next chord grip comes really easy.
  • I had 2 sessions today: in the first one I worked on chord changes only, in the second one I practiced both the phrases slowly counting out loud and tapping my foot; once more I had this relaxed well being feeling :slight_smile:

DAY 17 - Struggling to be focussed

…when I realised I was really struggling to concentrate, go slow and practice properly I thought that I still would make some productive random practice and did a considerable amount of practice on the triplet hammer on, which still doesn’t sound what it should. After that I practiced the second phrase as the focus seemed a bit regained, but surfing the fretboard is not easy; I noticed how doing the counting, tapping the foot and go along with it makes me feel relaxed despite a few unclean notes while without that timing reference for my fingers everything feels kind of scatty, I don’t feel within the music but rushing after it. I think it’s worth to practice so that I’m able to play on the beat and when I’ll be super confident with that I can start thinking how to make it my own.
I need to remind to myself that this is advanced for me and it’s really appropriate if it takes a lot of time to learn - I need to take small steps. Tomorrow I’ll do more and more repetitions on the whole 2 phrases, slow and tapping and feeling good. I will then isolate what seems to need more work.

DAY 18 - Only 5 minutes

Back to work this week, and to structured practice including Ear Training and Strumming - I haven’t practiced Dee for a couple of days now and feeling a bit guilty. There was no time today for it either, but I thought 5 minutes would be better than nothing and I started planning those 5 minutes early in the afternoon: “Before dinner I will find 5 minutes and I won’t focus on anything else than my triplet on bar one and make that hammer on stronger and clearer”. And that’s what I did.

DAY 19 - Balanced Practice

I well have in my head that I need to avoid getting obsessed by learning a song/piece and just practice without overdoing, accept the process while observing and accepting myself. So I’m much happy today with myself for having a 30 mins strumming session early in the morning and two close 20mins sessions, first revisiting my Alegretto and then…Dee! I started my practice with the counting and tapping …ugh those unclean notes! After some more repetitions on a few changes I tried to play it without tapping/counting…well it’s not actually that bad you know…and I do love the sound of that harmonics…who knows maybe I’ll record and share this weekend!

DAY 20 - The beat helps the fingers.

In today’s practice I reinforced the awareness that I don’t have to aim to make it my own so soon; the reason is simple: I’m not used to play through the whole fretboard, it is challenging for my fingers to make the wide movements and tapping the beat is hugely helpful for them, it’s like for them to know how, when and where to move to. So I practiced while tapping my foot and also trying to observe the unclean notes: just a little movement of the wrist toward the right makes the add of the 2 fingers down on the G chord more stable…and again ring finger needs to be’ curled! I practiced slowly trying to be careful on these aspects.

DAY 21- Recording and sharing Bars 1-13

:slight_smile: I think I’m now ready to move on learning the next bars - it’s far from being perfect insofar, but it’ll never be after all; what matters to me is timing to be decent enough and most notes being clean - refining is a lifelong goal. No need to say, it’s all well memorised, otherwise I wouldn’t move on.

5 Likes

The good thing about spending so much time on a single piece. Note by note, and then barr to barr is that by the time you get to the end of measure you really have it in the memory. I have found the same is mostly true with transcribing as well. Cool update.

1 Like

I still find your one-song-LL-project really fascinating :slightly_smiling_face:

Presumably you are taking notes along the way and you are then rephrasing them here? Does taking these notes help you understanding the song better - If so, does it make memorizing easier, and how?

1 Like

That looks like a challenging piece. It’s coming along nicely and the way that you’re tackling it including your write up will ensure that you consume every lesson to be learned from it.

1 Like

Hi Silvia,

I appreciate how much thought and planning you do when approaching music. Amazing work.

Jeff

1 Like

I agree, the more I train my ear to look for and find the notes of a melody the more easily it will find them.

Nicole @JokuMuu you always have very good questions.

I use the Notes App on my smartphone and when it’s time to post here I just do copy&paste; for some reason I can’t do it directly and I have to copy&past to a draft on my E-mail and from there I copy&paste here.

I’m not sure about this, I would say taking these notes helps me understanding how I’m learning it: writing things down help me to consolidate in my mind what I might have noticed today and easily forget tomorrow, like the position of wrist on a particular chord for example. Also write down how I felt while practicing is very helpful to self-assess if I were rushing and feeling struggling or on the contrary feeling well; here for example I noticed that going slow and tapping my foot makes me feel I have control over my fingers.

Not straight away. What really helps me with memorising is described here

And now that I wrote how I practiced without a guitar for bars 1-13 I can re-read it for the new bars to learn and see what was effective, what I struggled with and maybe also refine the way I practice.

Does this make sense to you? In the Perfect starts slowly lesson (Grade 3) Justin points out how keeping a journal or write an essay on what and how we’re learning can be beneficial; check the lesson, if you haven’t already as most of the things I’m writing I learnt from him.
It’s basically about being more thoughtful of what you’re doing, becoming more aware and thus making learning more effective as James says:

Adding Jeff as well @SDKissFan

THANK YOU ALL for taking the time to listen, I hope you read through the lines without spending too much time on the reading! :sweat_smile:

4 Likes

A little late to the party, I’m sorry. :sweat_smile:

Your learning diary is always worth a read and listen, Silvia. So deliberately taking time to go through it slowly is time spent well for me. :slight_smile:
I admire the way you are observing yourself, what works good, what need improvement, how the things actually feel. Probably I said that before, but this invaluable. But one of the most outstanding things you do (for me at least is this):

The way you can incorporate guitar practice without a guitar must be of such a great benefit. I wish I could do this, too, but my brain is just not wired for this kind of exercises. :sweat_smile:

1 Like