Harvest Moon by Neil Young

Community Recordings Audio-Video Of You Playing
1

Hey Folks, this is my second go at a video. All feedback is more than welcome! I have been strumming and taking justinguitar since May 13th of this year. I also have a great coach yes its that
@Richard_close2u fella!!! Hope you enjoy and I hope it helps someone. It seemed a little dark so I may need to adjust my lighting next time also hope to start singing someday! Thanks!

16 Likes
2

I really hate metronomeā€¦ but you made me moving my leg like you. I really like it. :slight_smile:

2 Likes
3

neil young, not diamond

1 Like
4

Thank you @LesPaulMoreRay

5

Hi Edward,
That was really good, nice steady tempo. You had me tapping my foot along also. Well done :clap:
Like you say a little more illumination from the front wouldnā€™t go a miss. Lovely song, I only discovered it recently and have been listening to it a lot. Thanks for sharing.
Best wishes,
Alan

1 Like
6

Nice strumming and chord changes. If you can get the setup so that we can hear the backing track as well, that would be nice.

Well done.

1 Like
7

Coming along nicely Edward. Strumming, good, chord changes, good and even tapping that foot.

The singing will come when you are ready.

1 Like
8

You are doing great Edward. As the others have already mentioned nice strumming and chord changes. Keep up the good work!

1 Like
9

Steady rhythm (great toe tapping, who needs a metronome!) and steady clean chords.
Yes, you need to change your setup. Easy one is the lighting. Donā€™t have a window behind you.
A more defined backing track would be good as it was barely audible and 5 minutes of strumming is a lot.
I look forward to you adding your vocal.
Well done Edward.

1 Like
10

Congratulations on your second recording, Edward :+1::clap:.
This was really steady strumming and foot tapping. Chord changes sounded clean, too.
All in all, lots to like :smiley:.
Keep on the good work!

1 Like
11

Well done on a second recording, Edward. Nothing I can add to whatā€™s already been said.

So just ā€˜bravo, keep on keeping on!ā€™

1 Like
12

Thanks to you all for the great feedback!

13

Hey Edward, itā€™s great to see you follow through with your intention to record and share another recording.
Iā€™m quite content to leave the comment to those before me who make some fair points and I can only endorse the positives re rhythm, strumming and keeping the beat. RE lighting, it isnā€™t that dark during lessons - is it the same camera you used?

2 Likes
14

Hi Edward!
That is impressive after that short amount of time! :clap::clap::clap:
I would guess you have spent a quite a few hours to get this down? Very very impressive, nice steady strumming and dynamics!
Well done!

1 Like
15

Greatā—ļø Iā€™m impressed with this short timeā—ļø Very solid. Keep on Edward. See you.

1 Like
16

That was great Edward! Amazing for only a few months!
I had my foot tapping along as well :smiley: and enjoyed listening :sunflower:

1 Like
17

Nice steady strumming. Weā€™ll done after such a short time playing. I love this song.

1 Like
18

Hi Edward,
Super good on your way, such a long song and then just keep going, for some listeners it may be a bit long, but for yourself these types of songs are really good to play often, keep it up :sunglasses: :clap:
Greetings,

1 Like
19

Hey Edward. Oh, you are moving right along very smoothly. Well done on your progress. Great form in all areas, in my opinion.

1 Like