Harvest Moon by Neil Young

Hey Folks, this is my second go at a video. All feedback is more than welcome! I have been strumming and taking justinguitar since May 13th of this year. I also have a great coach yes its that
@Richard_close2u fella!!! Hope you enjoy and I hope it helps someone. It seemed a little dark so I may need to adjust my lighting next time also hope to start singing someday! Thanks!

16 Likes

I really hate metronome… but you made me moving my leg like you. I really like it. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

neil young, not diamond

1 Like

Thank you @LesPaulMoreRay

Hi Edward,
That was really good, nice steady tempo. You had me tapping my foot along also. Well done :clap:
Like you say a little more illumination from the front wouldn’t go a miss. Lovely song, I only discovered it recently and have been listening to it a lot. Thanks for sharing.
Best wishes,
Alan

1 Like

Nice strumming and chord changes. If you can get the setup so that we can hear the backing track as well, that would be nice.

Well done.

1 Like

Coming along nicely Edward. Strumming, good, chord changes, good and even tapping that foot.

The singing will come when you are ready.

1 Like

You are doing great Edward. As the others have already mentioned nice strumming and chord changes. Keep up the good work!

1 Like

Steady rhythm (great toe tapping, who needs a metronome!) and steady clean chords.
Yes, you need to change your setup. Easy one is the lighting. Don’t have a window behind you.
A more defined backing track would be good as it was barely audible and 5 minutes of strumming is a lot.
I look forward to you adding your vocal.
Well done Edward.

1 Like

Congratulations on your second recording, Edward :+1::clap:.
This was really steady strumming and foot tapping. Chord changes sounded clean, too.
All in all, lots to like :smiley:.
Keep on the good work!

1 Like

Well done on a second recording, Edward. Nothing I can add to what’s already been said.

So just ‘bravo, keep on keeping on!’

1 Like

Thanks to you all for the great feedback!

Hey Edward, it’s great to see you follow through with your intention to record and share another recording.
I’m quite content to leave the comment to those before me who make some fair points and I can only endorse the positives re rhythm, strumming and keeping the beat. RE lighting, it isn’t that dark during lessons - is it the same camera you used?

2 Likes

Hi Edward!
That is impressive after that short amount of time! :clap::clap::clap:
I would guess you have spent a quite a few hours to get this down? Very very impressive, nice steady strumming and dynamics!
Well done!

1 Like

Great❗️ I’m impressed with this short time❗️ Very solid. Keep on Edward. See you.

1 Like

That was great Edward! Amazing for only a few months!
I had my foot tapping along as well :smiley: and enjoyed listening :sunflower:

1 Like

Nice steady strumming. We’ll done after such a short time playing. I love this song.

1 Like

Hi Edward,
Super good on your way, such a long song and then just keep going, for some listeners it may be a bit long, but for yourself these types of songs are really good to play often, keep it up :sunglasses: :clap:
Greetings,

1 Like

Hey Edward. Oh, you are moving right along very smoothly. Well done on your progress. Great form in all areas, in my opinion.

1 Like