You have already delivered fantastic work , you have shown and let heard so many good things here …again… and yes absolutely a work in process of course,
I know the song note by note by heart and the quiet parts in the beginning are still there a lot of hours of work before it runs smoothly, but I’m not telling you anything new with that.
That I can still read here that people don’t know this song right away as one by Metallica , one of the most (or just the most) famous metal song ever made, the song that put Metallica on the map worldwide among metal/rock fans I saw last month in a documentary … the 3 songs that make a band / artist iconic … it was my first hard rock song I think I heard and I was immediately hooked.
Dangerous to post such an iconic song, still far from ready, but very tough
Good luck with polishing because it’s in your head and fingers, it’s now “only” a matter of more practice, I’m already making a very deep bow to you,
Hi Rogier, great to hear from you and thanks for your kind words and encouragement!
You are spot on my friend! Lots of practice still needed to get that right and securely under my fingers. Also there are some many other layers that I could look to learn, I’ve really only scratched the surface and still grappling just with that
Yeah, it is right up there, perhaps Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters probably top it in widespread popularity, but it was their initial massive mainstream breakthrough. Due to the video and all that MTV airtime, many old school fans began murmuring about them selling out… little did they know what was coming next!
Yes, I was a bit nervous about that, I wanted to put flashing lights on the “work in progress” disclaimer I really needed to move on for now as other things are taking priority but I had put so much time into it I had to do something with it, so a snapshot of progress seemed a good idea
Those other songs were treated as number 2 and number 3 in that program… I’ve been looking for it for a while but can’t find it that quickly, and the black album contained/are very good songs, I remember the evening when the whole CD was played for the first time on Dutch radio, and there were certainly many mixed feelings, which were confirmed at the first concert after that, where I and my neighbor went to … grown people in a neat jacket
Work on progress was more than enough as a warning… super good to post it because the pressure and practice that entails helps you / us a lot further
Edit;I do remember that Enter Sandman was made by letting the band members tell their nightmares and they used that.
Thanks Eddie! Yes, despite some of what I said above , I am happy to get to this point, of course much more to learn but certainly pleased to have got this far
Thanks so much for checking this out and for your kind words mate, super appreciate it!
Not much I can add to what others have said other than good job man If i can play a fraction of that someday then I’ll be very happy indeed
I think one thing that can be misunderstood about metal is that it’s harder than people think to make a lot of noise AND sound good AND be able to play it again and again consistently!
One of my practice routines at the moment is playing power chords to a metronome but it’s a lot more fun with the amp turned up and lashings of fuzz
For me this album is quite significant because it was just out as I was starting to get into metal at the end of the 80s so I’ve listened to it A LOT!!! It’s somewhat scary to think that it’s 35 years since it was released
Oh yes ! Unfortunately others in my house disagree…but I get a big smile on my face, playing ffw a few years, maybe my grandchildren answer the question from their friends: “What kind of noise is that?” with: “Oh, that’s my grandmother, playing the soul out of her guitar !”
I completely underestimated how difficult it is to use them in songs and to speed them up for being able to play songs . And don’t talk about the speed needed to play lead. I reckon, I’ll never get there in my life anymore…so hats off for everyone being capable to get there .
Hello Jeff, this One is part of those very few Metallica 'songs I know It seems to me you’re doing an amazing job as it sounds great! As you can imagine I wouldn’t be able to say how you’ll improve it but I was happy to read you’re overall happy with it, this is for sure something to be proud of! I also enjoyed the production of the video, it seems so difficult to synch the audios, are you using any particular software or app? Bravo!
Hi Silvia Thanks so much for checking this out and for your kind words!
Yes, I’m doing all the post-production in DaVinci Resolve, using the free version of this video editing software from Blackmagic. From my research, this is the best free editor out there, in fact it was originally recommended to me from our Media Production techs at the university I work at. I’ve found it great and certainly makes putting together more complex productions much easier. If you’ve worked with Adobe Premier or, say, OpenShot, then the learning curve won’t be too difficult. Otherwise there are good help videos on their website or YouTube. In saying that, I enjoy this sort of stuff and like spending time learning it, however could imagine others finding it unnecessary time away from the guitar!
Tallica at their classic best - and an awesome live song.
Absolutely nailed the bridge into the solo. Great stamina. Makes you appreciate how these guys keep it going for an whole gig.
Air drumming was going 10 to the dozen.
I’ll bite David.
“JK, I’m sure you are right and as equally sure many would say One is one of U2’s best songs and better than all but a few of Metallica’s songs, those being their best songs off that Black Album …”
One of U2s best songs - for sure.
Better than all but a few Tallica songs - define few. Lol. Wouldn’t even get inside 'Tallica’s top 20.
Great job on this one! You are pretty much aware of things that need working on so well on this. Plus, thank you for inspiring me to return to this one and try to fully learn it after a decade (or maybe even 15 years)!
If you get a chance, go and see Metallica live. They are on fire! And their new album is made to be played live in my opinion. “One” is also one of the best songs to show how well James’ vocal aged.
Rad! Soooooo jealous you’ve seen them playing recently and got to hear their new stuff live! Agreed, I think it would be much better hearing those tracks live than the polished album version. I have my fingers crossed that they come back to NZ some time soon, would love to see them live again. Last time was back in 2008 (front row standing right beneath the stage - it was epic! ). I did have a top tier ticket to see them again in 2019 but it got cancelled as James had to go back to rehab
Thanks Jeff, I don’t find it to be unnecessary, on the contrary I would like to be better at production and I’m taking a note of this to check it out when I’ll finally decide to spend some time on it…and I’m very happy it’s free, as I wouldn’t spend money for it because…guess what?.. I want to buy a new guitar