I also want to play fingerstyle and classical guitar. However, after working at that quite a bit, I realized that I needed to go back and learn strumming and strummed songs better. Not only do I need the rhythm basics strumming teaches in order to play fingerstyle (and classical too) I needed some less complicated successes to bolster my sense of achievement.
I am seconding this too. I had a fingerstyle phase with YT channels like SixString. But, in the end, it did lower my motivation because even the easy lead melody arrangements takes a lot of time to master at our level. It did not feel as fun as I thought given all the time that I had to invest. I had way more fun sticking with Justin Songs which are more about rhythm guitar (chords or fingerstyle) as itās closer to the skills that we learn in the course. Itās not like starting over something new, itās a continuity.
It also is easier to learn rhythm and timing with strumming and chord structures than it is to learn it while trying to learn fingerstyle, especially if it isnāt a simple, repetitive picking pattern.
Rhythm and timing is important. Possibly the most important.
Thatās been it for me. After you get a few songs in your pocket, add some variety. Many use the āold faithfulā strum pattern D D u u D u. Introduce some new strumming patterns/rhythms or start some fingerstyle.
Justin has an excellent lesson on thumb and finger technique that gave me a great strum with a back beat that just suits certain songs.
I canāt remember where I heard this, but I think itās very wise:
āDonāt compare yourself to other players. Compare yourself to the player you were a year agoā
Also, learning guitar is not a linear processā¦it often proceeds in fits and starts, with long plateaus, and sudden jumps to the next level.
Iāve had many periods of frustration. But I have come to realize that this is often a prelude to a jump to the next level of playing. You kinda have to just tough it out.
A lot of great info here already, as youād expect from this great community.
A couple of things, if I may.
I think its a good idea to change it up for bit; take a break from the strict JG lesson format, as youāve intimated. It may be the circuit breaker you need. As others have said, find a few songs you like, and have a go at them, without any pressure.
Eventually, I think its always a good idea to do a thorough and honest review of your weaknesses, and strengths, being very specific about both. That way, you can seek, find, experiment with practice routines that attack those weaknesses with laser like focus.
Along the lines of @Jamolay input.
Iāve always seen learning, of any type, as a journey from initial knowledge to full competency. The knowledge part is at the lowest level. It is the fun part - novel, often exciting and stimulating, often full of wonder. The move towards competency is the hard part; bringing that knowledge together and expressing it creatively on the guitar. Itās often littered with frustration, temporary failures, trial and error etc. It has to be. But itās also filled with much joy, progress, fulfillment.
I thinks that itās consistently finding the joy in the second part of the journey that keeps you going.
I took a day so I can have a look on guitars and some stylesā¦ also I go keyboard Yamaha at home, but I am too lazy for that now.
I checked some Furch Little Jane and I really like it, but maybe some dayā¦ this is not the way for me.
I checked fingerstyle and thats good, but they all offer only intros and if you want play whole song it is really complex and hard. So this is not the way too.
I checked country style and I pretty like it with lot of hammer ons, but I checked few songs and they just dont touch my heart how I would like to. So this is not the way right now tooā¦
I think youāve also got to bear in mind that the likes of the song lessons done by Six Strings is aimed at a playing level similar to his course structures. A bit like how Justin teaches you how to play some chords and strumming patterns and gives you some suggested songs.
Yes, SixString fingerpicking course and song lessons definitely seems great. I might do this course or the one from Joe Robinson in 2 years when I have achieved my current JustinGuitar goals (blues and rock). I now focus on one course/genre at a time as Justin says in grade 3.
Itās great to see that Careta is having fun with his Simple Plan songs. Itās a great band !