Hi all. Iāve been playing about 7 years on guitar and 3 on piano.
I have a really bad natural ear for hearing and playing back melodies or knowing the key of a song and chord progressions.
Iāve tried apps, methods from you tube but never really seem to improve.
Has anyone who was ābadā at this actually found a method that has improved them? As much as I enjoy playing songs from Justinās books etc I feel like I am destined to never be even a little bit of a musician without this skill
Hi maybe this stuff helpsā¦
Type ā¦ear trainer ā¦ in the search venster and you will find moreā¦good luck and welcome here Dan 
Greetings,Rogier
2 Likes
Hi Dan
Iāve used various apps for ear training, interval training etc but the problem is that although I get ok at hearing intervals, pulling chords and melodies from real songs is much harder.
I think the best way is to dive into real songs. I started with fairly simple stuff (I did the Greenday back catalog for example) mostly I IV V and VIm stuff.
Just keep at it, I try and do a little transcribing every day.
Good luck!
Paul
1 Like
You probably already know this, but the Grade 3 course on the website contains quite a few transcribing challenges (I think there is one of these vids in each of these modules, but not 100% sure about this). These are awesome for this in my opinion, Justin gives harder and more complex challenges each module (starting with single notes, then power chords, then open chords etc.).
If you havenāt already, I recommend trying to do these (take your time, donāt rush through it), it is really fun in my opinion.
1 Like
Hey Dan, you already have the best ear training app you can buy - your guitar! Listen to it, really listen to it when youāre playing.
When you first start to train your ear, the intervals may seem quite close together but as you progress your mind will start to separate them and hear them better.
Follow Justinās ear training course. Play an interval over and over.
Can you hear it in your mind?
Play the first note then try to hear the second note in your mind - then play it. Were you right?
Thereās all sorts you can do on guitar that will help but donāt expect instant results. It takes time.
Another good one is to try to hear the individual notes of a chord when you strum it.
Start simple. Play the open Cmajor chord, just the lowest three notes on strings 5,4 & 3
The notes are C E G
Play the C note then strum all 3 strings. Can you hear that C note? Itās the lowest note.
Do the same with the G note. Can you hear it? Itās the highest note.
The hardest one to hear is the E because itās in the middle!
It all takes time but if you keep doing these sort of things, youāre mind/ear will sort it all out.
1 Like
Thank you so much for all your suggestions.
I have heard about trying to hear the individual notes of a chord previously.
And assigning intervals to known songs i.e star ears perfect 5th etc.
Iām not sure if Iāve given enough time to whichever method and expected results too soon.
Most recently I saw a video on playing through the major scale while listening to a track and just switching to each different key until it sounded right, then working out the chords after when the key is identified.
Seemed decent with the sort of ābacking trackā provided but not so much with real song with a lot noise more going on.
Maybe I should give Justinās transcribing course a good go. I donāt think trying to score points on ear training apps is working for me!
Thanks again.
1 Like
This is definitely my problem, a common one at that.
I think trying to score points on an app isnāt a particularly good way to train your ear.
Combining all the things mentioned on this thread will be far better. Bit of this bit of that.
1 Like
Hi Dan, welcome to the community! Iām afraid there is no quick fix for this. My (long and winding) road towards a musical ear started with the lessons linked in @roger_holland Rogierās reply, then the Transcribing lessons introduced in grade 3 - which is where I am now, making slow progress, because Iām always reluctant to practice something I donāt feel confident doing. Which, while itās human nature, is kind of self-defeating. One of Justinās maxims, which I really need to internalise, is āpractice what you canāt do, not what you canā
2 Likes
Hi Dan,
Welcome to the community 
Iām no expert but another suggestion that might work for you (pretty sure Justin mentioned it in an ear training video)
as well as really listening when you play songs or intervals or just playing a note, to sing it, even softly to yourself, so you also feel it and internalise it 
1 Like