Stratocaster or Telecaster - Why You Chose One?

@Carreta
I don’t want to kill your dream but if you think buying a Tele is going to make you sound like Robben Ford I have some bad news. His tele is far from off the rack.

Robben Ford is known for playing a 1960 Fender Telecaster, particularly one with a Blonde finish and a slab Rosewood fretboard. It features a custom-wound neck pickup and a bridge pickup calibrated to match the neck pickup

So I’d spend my time practicing and getting good with the guitars you already have than chasing a sound you may never find.

2 Likes

I as a player agree, I want to have more than one guitar.

1 Like

:joy::rofl:
Guys I am 100% sure no one said that. But at the same time I don’t think there is anything wrong with wanting to emulate someone you admire.

There are plenty of people who started playing guitar and use a strat because Stevie Ray Von played one, a lot of others started with a LesPaul beacause Jimmy Page played one.

I honesty dont think its a bad place to start. As long as you sit with one and give it a go to make sure it feels right, you can up grade parts as you find the sound your want for yourself.

2 Likes

Well looks like you are already there. Time to buy some parts.

1 Like

I agree and there are plenty of people who buy loads of gear thinking it will make them sound like SRV or Jimmy Page when in reality the only way you’ll sound anything like your guitar hero is to practice.

2 Likes

Joe Bonamassa on what guitar he’d have if he could only have one.

1 Like

The main reason I prefer Strats to any other electric I’ve tried?

Ergonomics.

A strat (or strat copy - I’ve got a borrowed Ibanez at the moment) feels more comfortable to play (for me) than any other electric…and all acoustics.

1 Like

Fair do’s, Jason,
but I 100% don’t buy a guitar simply because someone famous has one. I buy a guitar because I like it and I know it’s down to me to be able to play it anything like as good as them.

3 Likes

I built it and it works! I am gonna reply to all tomorrow, I am exhausted. Thanks all for great comments. :blush:

6 Likes

With Justin watching you, you are sure to repeat the practice mantras. :joy:

I am super stoked you put it togeather bro. Heck yeah man.

Woot woot and it looks like you had all the parts on hand. So you didnt have to spend any extra money.
:fire::sign_of_the_horns:t2:

1 Like

haha! :slight_smile:

So you had some kit there already? Wonderful! :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:
The headstock could need some shape embellishing, in case you will be bored one day :slight_smile: But there’s certainly other more important things than that!

1 Like

Talking single coils here, I say get both, as these are two of the great electric guitar tone platforms. The tele bridge is really everything a guitar player is going to need and then some --except for the strat neck pickup which is smooth, sweet, hot, buttery goodness.
My tele in the bridge position:
#short rat blues
My strat in the neck position:
gilmour or less

2 Likes

I have 3 teles and one Strat. The 3 teles are 2 Squier affinity’s and one classic vibe. My strat was made by me out of really top quality parts and cost about the same as the 3 teles put together.

And …. I play the 2 cheap affinity’s 95% of the time. I got my 2nd affinity for 50 bucks in terrible condition and completely restored it and it’s perfect. Cost me about 200 bucks in total and it’s just a great guitar now. The 2 guitars have 2 different sets of pickups. Tonerider Alnico 2 blues in one and a pair of hot Iron Gear Steel Foundries overwound in the one I renovated. 2 completely different sounds from the same guitar platform and both super easy to play. The toneriders are beautiful for clean sounds I love it. The steel foundries are HOT and great for rock and blues.

My classic vibe tele is relegated to my 2nd residence. It’s more expensive but just not as nice to play, even though it has great tone and lovely pickups and looks super cool (olive green with cream double binding)

Why do I prefer the telecaster? For me , it just looks so much cooler than a Strat or any other guitar. But it’s much more. I find it incredible that with all the amazing advances in technology the tele, which is such a simple design, is still one of the most popular guitars and has really changed very little since 1951. I can’t think of many other products where a design has been so successful for so long (except the Strat :grinning_face::grinning_face:). They are easy to build and super easy to modify. I like the simplicity of 2 pickups and a 3 way switch. I wired my hot tele with a 4 way switch and the 4th position absolutely rocks.

The two pickup sets are totally different. Toneriders for clean stuff and so smooth and the Iron Gear for rock/ blues sounds. With the iron gears and the 4th position you don’t need humbuckers.

So what about the Strat? Well I was completely surprised how different a Strat sounds from a tele. My Strat really chimes and is bell like whereas the tele is harder and more brittle. I think you can get a greater range of tones out of the Strat, but for me, the controls are more complicated and I have to work more to get the right tone, but it’s great when you find it. I gravitate to the teles over the Strat because they feel nicer and easier to play. However, I still have to make some adjustments to the Strat which might greatly improve playability and may completely change things.

So all in all, both are great but I have a strong preference for the tele mainly for ease of play. If I was a better guitarist, I suspect I would use the Strat more as I would be able to exploit its excellent tonal qualities but for me, as a beginner, it’s more complicated.

Also I should add (and this is probably sacrilege) that I never use the tele bridge on its own (even though that’s one of its strengths) and mostly use the middle and neck position and I mostly use the middle position on the Strat, which many people ignore in favour of the neck or positions 2 and 4. The Strat middle position rocks.

Oh and ā€œThe Bossā€ plays a tele. That’s good enough for me!!! :grinning_face::grinning_face::grinning_face:

3 Likes

@Guitarman63 What a great collection. :slight_smile: I was looking for some of your recordings and did not find it. :slight_smile:

@Ontime Thank you, I can remember you are into luthiering too when it comes to electric guitar. I am pretty sure you are getting 100% out of your guitars.
Do you plan to buy Tele anytime soon?
Yeah, I am happy I found all the parts and everything seems like works even better than on 3D printed body.

@BurnsRhythm Interesting point. I am not looking for ā€œexact same guitarā€ as someone. I am sure it cost much much more and also that is not my target. Some color variants are just… ugly to me and many people are happy for them. This is really about preference. I was just looking for some stories and what bond you to one or other camp. :slight_smile:

@stitch I did not mean it like I wanna buy or look for guitar so I will sound like someone. I already know this truth. :smiley: I was saying that watching those guys playing inspires to pick some instrument… same like when someone watch Billy String inspire pick acoustic, watching Gilmore wanna pick Strat etc… I already figured it out, because I was able to build Tele from parts I have at home. :smiley:

@Tbushell Hey Tom, this is really interesting. For me it is exactly opposite. I am acoustic guitar player (sitting only) and comfort is much to me. Yesterday late night I tried to plug in that Tele and I can already say it is much much comfortable for me than Strat and reason is the shape is not that rounded with bewels, it is little bit thicker and ALSO there is no pick up in the middle section of picking hand. That is something I really dont like while fingerpicking, because I am touching that part here.

@domi7 I have and it works! The headstock looks like hockey stick and I have at home all tools to shape it, so soon or later… it will come. :smiley:

1 Like

@CT Thank you for sharing samples. You are playing really good. I wish I could improvise on the neck like you - that is main reason why I like the electric, because you ā€œneed toā€ travel around whole neck. Playing open chords here like on acoustic is not that good. :smiley:
I think hardest part will be trying to learn play electric, so it sound like something for me.

@Prof_Thunder Interesting reading here. :slight_smile:
I really agree with you that Strat feels much more complicated than Tele. I just want guitar like acoustic, that I just pick and play and it works. :smiley: Yesterday late night I tried 3 positions and middle and neck position will be the way. I think middle position sounds best to me, but I can see many players are able to switch or mess with tone and volume during playing. :smiley:
Well… I am 28 and something just looks and magnify me more on Tele visual than on Strat. It is like… I am really enjoying some old music and sometimes I think about I would love to live back in that days than what is modern now. Of course I am talking about that more in American way, I am not sure if I wanna live in Czech Republic in that times because there was communism and it was really hard to get guitar here - that is beginning of story for Frantisek Furch, who bought old piano from neighbours and crafted few homemade guitars from that. :smiley: Than started to sell and produce for guys in pub. It was not legal. :smiley:

1 Like

Loved those 2 clips of the tele and the strat @CT

Great tones.

2 Likes

Hi Michal. I went to Prague as a phd student in 1988 for a conference. It was really difficult just to get the visa, let alone buy anything when you were in the country. It was a truly wonderful and surreal experience to visit communist Czechoslovakia. But actually I met a phd student there called Miroslav and we’ve been great friends ever since and in 1988 he had an acoustic guitar. He still plays and his wife now has a huge collection of electric guitars. .they were available then but not American brands. Most things for normal people there were not great at that time it’s true but there were some advantages. I walked around all the historic sites in prague without another tourist in site. I walked across the Charles Bridge on a Sunday morning with mist coming off the river snd swirling around the statues without another person in site. Very atmospheric. Unimaginable today. It’s a wonderful memory.

1 Like

@Prof_Thunder What a great memory for you. :slight_smile:
Sadly I cant feel same, because I live 20-30 minutes from Prague and there are really many tourists…

On the other hand when I was in London last year I really enjoyed the places I know from movies and games… so I am pretty sure it is some psychological fact. Like someone who live by and see Eiffel Tower every day… he just does not care. :smiley:

I can remember from older movies and facts… that we were not able to play some music genres or express our opinions too much. :smiley:

2 Likes

Now you tell me. :slightly_smiling_face:

2 Likes

The reason I started playing was because of Hank Marvin and his red and white strat I know playing different guitars will not make me sound like my hero’s, but I like them and the one I play most is my White Tele.