What's the strumming pattern for Travelin' Soldier by The Chicks

I’ve been trying to figure this out for days but I’ve hit a wall. There are several lessons on youtube and elsewhere but each one has a different strumming pattern. It might be further complicated because there are different live and studio versions of the song. I’m sure I’ve got the right chords but any suggestions on a strumming pattern would be greatly appreciated.

This is the live version I’m trying to learn. You can clearly see Natalie Maines’ hand as she’s playing but I still can’t get it. I suspect the start of the song is off beat, she start’s with an upstroke but I think that might be the 3+ beat.

Hi Chris,

I’m sure there’s others that will jump in to actually answer this, however, great song I used follow these way back in the Dixie Chicks era, even used play Not Ready To Make Nice.

I like this live version, perhaps we’ll hear your rendition at some stage :+1:

As for strumming pattern, “feel the force, Luke” :love_you_gesture:

1 Like

I don’t have a specific answer but when I’m trying to work out a pattern I find that humming along with the rhythm of the song gives me something that works, and that’s the thing, it’s a question that will have more than one right answer.

Sometimes I’ve used a voice recording app to record me humming along and then I can loop it and see if I can match the pattern just playing with muted strings

1 Like

This is pretty much what she strums for the first part of the song. She does start on an offbeat. Occasionally, she misses a strum but this is the what she does most of the time.

2 Likes

Hey @chris_m , I had a listen and here’s how I hear it…

There are minor variations throughout the song (I didn’t listen to all of it), but the main vibe goes something like this (using 8th note strumming):

1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + | 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 +
D   D U D   D U | D U D U D U D U

with fairly heavy accents on the 1 and 3 downstrums in the 1st bar.

Actually, she often doesn’t play all those strums in the 2nd bar. For example, sometimes I hear this:

1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + | 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 +
D   D U D   D U |   U D   D U D 

I’m not sure of your level, but here’s how I would approach the strumming: play the 1st bar of the pattern consistently as I wrote above, with accents on 1 and 3. For bar 2, I would start with the 2nd version above, get it solid, but then be open to changing it. You could put the downstrum on 1 back in, or add an upstrum on the “and of 4”, for example.

I think if you keep bar 1 consistent and play around with bar 2, you will sound pretty good. Good luck!

1 Like

Thank you all for the feedback. That gives me a starting point to play around with.

Cool little song I like it cheers Hec

1 Like

Hi @chris_m I have listened to the song now and I hear it differently to Dave @Dave_Birnie and john @jjw. I hear the verses as 16-th note strumming with strong accents on the backbeats (that’s 2 and 4). For the chorus she ups the accents a bit - it still is 16th note strumming with accents on backbeats but twice the tempo, so accents at 1a, 2a, 3a and 4a. Then back to slightly slimmer strumming for the next verse. Let me see if I can write this out here.

Verse:

        >               >
1 e a e 2 e a e 3 e a e 4 e a e
D       D   d u D   d u D   d u

I’ve used large and small letters to show which strums are more important (and are played louder / stronger). Those are actually all the main 1-2-3-4 beats, with the additional accents on the 2 and 4. She hardly plays any strums ever on the 1e, 2e, 3e and 4e, but she plays additional audible down-up strums on 2a and 2ae and the same on the 3a and 3ae and 4a and 4ae. But they are played softer. That then adds layers to the strumming.

For the 16th note strumming its important that you have continuous arm movemement, even when you are not planning to hit any strings (like on the 1a). That is the basis for varying up the pattern a bit throughout the verses, but I would try variations only once you can hold a repeating pattern with accents alwasy in the right place etc. For example Natalie sometimes also plays strums on the 1a (just not in the very first bars of the first verse) and sometimes she drops down strums (but never the ones on 2 or 4 as far as I can hear) and plays a string of 3 up strums on the -e-'s.

The strum at the start of the song is btw the up strum on the 4eae - the second strum is the down strum on beat 1 of the first bar.

Chorus:
The strumming in the chorus gets busier, and I clearly hear her throwing in extra accents in a few bars on the 1a and then the next -a- beats, although she does not keep it up beyond a few bars and then reverts back to the main accents on the backbeats 2 and 4. This would look like something like this (although her strumming is loose in the sense there is no fixed repeat patter of which and how many up strums she hits etc)

    >       >       >       >
1 e a e 2 e a e 3 e a e 4 e a e 
D   D   d u D u d   D   d u D u

Changing where to put accents between verse and chorus is a tricky business, so you could just play the chorus with keeping accents on 2 and 4 and just play a few more strums, or just add the accent on the 1a - that one really stands out from me because it changes the groove from “1 - accent on 2” to “1 - accent on a - 2” and creates the illusion that the tempo doubles up (which it doesn’t of course - its smoke and mirrors!).

Hope that gives you some more ideas. And I agree with Hec, lovely song! Share a recording with us when you have it down!

2 Likes

OMG @MollyT that’s quite a comprehensive analysis. As it happens I’ve been doing some practice on 16th note strumming, it’s also in another song I’m learning, One by U2. I’ve got the general idea, Justin has a lesson on the flick of the wrist to get the speed for 16th note strumming. But I’m still some way off from been able to do it with accents or chord embellishments. I can see why you need to add some variations, there are long sections on a G chord which gets monotonous without something extra.

Oh perfect timing then - here you have another song to practise the 16th note strumming. I find that one is a skill that really needs time to develop - and I say that because mine is nowhere where I would like it to be despite years of trying. Like other things on guitar it will come with time, patience and practise, so every now and then I work a few weeks on a song with 16th note strumming but then let it rest and “cure” :slight_smile: . So with this song what you could do is play along with the recording and use the following pattern:

        >               >
1 e a e 2 e a e 3 e a e 4 e a e
D   d   D   d u D   d   D   d u

That is regular enough (eight downstrums each bar) and just two up strums before the 1 and 3 and that should leave enough room to then try and experiment with different emphasis on the strums - the 2 and 4 get the heaviest strum and the strums on the -a- beats are the weakest with the strums on 1 and 3 somewhere in the middle. That should get you grooving.

3 Likes