What's Up by 4 Non Blondes Lesson

So I’ve been trying to play this with the app and checked in here to see about strumming patterns. And I see a Capo on the 2nd fret which the app doesn’t mention as far as I can tell. So should the capo be used with the App version as, obviously, it doesn’t have the Bm Justin mentions to not use a cap. Anyway, I’ll try it both ways tomorrow. Thanks for the lesson though who knows if I’ll be able to master that strumming pattern! ACK!

1 Like

Rebecca, I learned the song with the capo. The capo is used to make the chords easier for the beginner. If you’re not going to use the capo then it is different chords, including the Bm.

2 Likes

I put the capo on the 2nd fret today and tried it with the App and it sounded HORRENDOUS. The sounds from my guitar and the App do not mesh!! I’m not sure what this means but it sounds great with the App when there is no capo used. I turned the app off and just played the chords with the capo and it sounded fine. So, there is some sort of disconnect with the app version using the G, C and Am chords and no capo and the capo on the second fret without the app.

So, am I missing something fundamental? According to the tuner that comes with the App my Bullet is in tune, same as when I tune with my clip-on tuner.

1 Like

The correct way to play What’s Up is with no capo and the chords are A, Bm and D, Justin teaches it with a capo on the 2nd fret using the chord shapes of G, Am and C to avoid the Bm barre chord but staying in the key of A

If the chords on the app are G, Am and C with no capo then the song has been transposed to the key of G.

3 Likes

This is confusing especially as the Beginners Songbook shows this with the strumming pattern over two bars, as noted by CliffM above. I’m assuming that the Songbook is wrong.

1 Like

Yup, I watched the video lesson and read the book section several times and determined the book is, indeed, wrong.

I have to say that when you add the fancy strumming pattern the song sounds WAY COOL!

1 Like

Justin says at about 8:48 in the lesson that the count is indeed 16th notes, but that beginners haven’t yet learned 16th note counting (not introduced until grade 3). So in the book, he’s “translated” the 16th note pattern into two 8th note bars. He does this in the lesson for One by U2 as well - it’s worth taking a look at the Strumming Pattern section at 05:27. I’ve tried counting 16th notes, and am awful at it at this point in my journey. I have other fish to fry just now, so I’ll use the two-bar 8th note trick!

2 Likes

Yeah, I remember him saying something about that, BUT, to me, that means half of the strumming pattern would be played for the first 4 beats and the other half of the pattern for the next for beats which is a different chord. I haven’t listened to the original song lately, but on the App, it’s definitely using the entire pattern for each 4 beat chord change.

1 Like

Oh, I see. I interpreted it to mean playing each bar as if they were two. That is, play the entire two-bar strumming pattern in each bar, so it matches with the song. It’s just counted differently. And to be honest, I just realized that I don’t really count it, but rather my mind is thinking “down/down-up/down” and so on. That might be a bad habit - thanks for leading me to that realization!

1 Like

If you split a 16th note strumming pattern into two 8th note strumming patterns the the first two beats of the bar is the first 8th note pattern and the last beats of the bar is the 2nd 8th note strumming pattern. So the first 1&2&3&4& is the 1e&a2e&a and the 2nd 1&2&3&4& is the 3e&a4e&a.

1 Like

Indeed it does!

2 Likes

Unfortunately, when I tried singing today everything went wrong. :rofl: So, no singing with the new pattern quite yet.

1 Like

Singing!! Oh no, not for me. It’s raining bad enough as it is.

2 Likes

The singing part I didn’t find too bad, it was when Linda hums that I found really difficult and it took me ages to get that.

2 Likes

There’s humming? I suppose I ought to listen to the original. But I suspect you don’t have to hum if you don’t want to.

1 Like

Yes, the humming comes between the pre-chorus and the chorus but give the original a listen. Of course not, remember you’re making it your own.

1 Like

Rebecca its more woohoo ooing than humming but its certainly not words. Definitely worth a listen to the original, not only for that but the whole vibe of the song.

Edit for the live official vid. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6NXnxTNIWkc

2 Likes

The music video is very helpful because if you watch carefully you can see she is not using an A barre cord at the 5th fret as Justin surmised, but is instead using more of a hybrid traditional/power A chord on the 2nd fret with her thumb wrapped over the top to mute the low E string. But Justin’s video description of how she is letting the open strings ring out in the chord transitions seems bang on. What an awesome song!

1 Like

Hi David welcome to the forum and glad the video helped. Always good to put things into persepective.

Why not pop over HERE and introduce yourself.

:sunglasses:

1 Like

A great tune and another excellent lesson by Justin. I am now playing in a band and this song is in our set. I am currently trying to learn the lead line on my electric guitar.