I remember joining the community back in early 2022 and being amazed at this community of guitar learners on Justin’s site. I stumbled here shortly after the old Disqus comments were turned off.
My favourite section was AVOYP - learners of all levels posting videos, and getting feedback and tips on their playing. Some reasonably early stage learners through to people that had achievable but beyond-me playing, through to semi-pros.
After watching a LOT of videos, I posted my first video and got some inspiring feedback. Some positive stuff. A few “attaboys”. Lots of tips. I was strumming over the neck. Posture, the way my fingers were picking the strings. My terrible singing at the time (lol…). All done in a constructive way.
For the most part, a spade was called a spade. Politely and encouragingly.
Over the past few months I’ve observed a tendency for more and more feedback to be effusively positive.
Now when a recording is outrageously good, that makes sense (and some of the recordings here are). But I don’t think it’s a good trend for when a recording has some very clear flaws, or there are playing tips for the person sharing. This is a guitar learning site, right?
Positive feedback for everything has the effect of devaluing the feedback overall. What separates good playing from poor playing when the feedback is the same? Of course, keeping in mind the level that someone is at.
Personally I take the view that I try to look for constructive feedback in each video I watch. Positive stuff. Constructive improvements. I could name the other members that do the same. However I feel the pendulum has swung too far towards positivity, even when it’s not warranted (toxic positivity, if anyone’s aware of that term).
Be polite. Don’t be mean. Be encouraging. Those are all good. Being positive about everything? Not as useful as genuine feedback IMHO.
Thoughts?