Who could, only after practice, sing in tune?

[jkahn]

@Jozsef

In my opinion, being able to hit certain notes is one thing, but doing it in a way that you do not injure yourself

Not too worried about injury… I figure I can’t do any worse than what I have been.

@lewis2025

I decided a couple of years ago that I wanted to sing properly and listening back to recordings of my early attempts I realise my pitch has improved a lot.

@lewis2025 Thanks for sharing. I’ve listened to your recordings before and you’re a good singer now IMHO. Perhaps the “years” vs “months” is important - I haven’t been trying for that long. Only a handful of months ago did I learn that singers sang notes! Such basic understanding but I had no idea. I can hear when I’m off pitch but not when singing without headphones.

@batwoman

You sing much better than you realise JK.

I’m only uploading what I think are “decent” recordings, most of my casual singing is terrible, and I know the ones I upload are miles off what they should be. Objectively, from a tune POV.

@DarrellW

It’s not that I am tone deaf because I can relatively easily transcribe to guitar and play by ear, it’s just that my voice doesn’t do what I feel it should be doing

You described what I feel like @DarrellW. I can hear notes and melodies, transcribe a bit (although pretty basic there), but can’t reproduce the sound I hear in my head.